It would be a fairly lengthy process, so it wouldn't happen all at once. Polls would be used of course. I'll even have different(and maybe better) categories to see who the best are according to strike 3 (cause the old voters are too busy giving the West Wing awards). Of course, to even start things off, I would list X number of potential candidates per award and it would be up to you all to pick 5 to go on for the final vote. That way, I'm not picking the top 5 cause I might be biased (for example, I don't like Arrested Development).
Thoughts, opinions, nagging pains in your thigh?