Public Knowledge of Rejected Deals

[missionhockey21]

As with most major league changes, the league will vote and the action from that will be the course we take.

Should rejected deals be posted to a sub-forum of transactions with an explanation as to why they failed? These threads would be closed and not up for discussion but it would help to identify common trends of what kind of deals are failing as well as potentially opening up for new offers from other teams. I think in the S3SL there is also a misperception that deals are often rejected and I think last year we had 4 or 5 at the most rejected (I have serious doubts that even 5 were), so this could perhaps show that deals usually fly through.

I don't want to have a discussion to the discussion, just a yes or a no on the issue. We need at least 16 votes on either side for this to happen, votes will be public to ensure we have only S3SL votes, and if we don't hit 16, we won't do it.

[HafDawg2003]

[cjkalt]

Would we be allowed to PM you for clarification for future notice or no?

[missionhockey21]

Whoever posts the deal to that forum should be the contact on it, but yes.

[Slyder]

I kind of like how Molina does his. Maybe a snipet on why it was rejected.

[zodious]

I say yes, it would help sometimes clarify how the TC views certain players value.

[Impossibles]

no

[HafDawg2003]

I put no for the simple reason that I actually value the sim league and want to avoid anything that creates more work for mish.

thx

<3 HafDawg2003 <3

[Providence A's]

I nominate Haf for the job. Seconded?

[HafDawg2003]

I nominate Haf for the job. Seconded?

I lub u.

[Saber]

Impossibles wants changes in the council, but not to see what we reject?

Now that piques the lawyer's interests....

[Kingdom]

A lot of times, mission has Saber or I notify people of failed deals. I would expect the same here and I would not have a problem with it. And saber won't either if enough liquor is involved

[Hammer]

if enough liquor is involved, ill ramble for a while about why your trades suck too.

[Kingdom]

Sweet

[Impossibles]

Impossibles wants changes in the council, but not to see what we reject?

Now that piques the lawyer's interests....

posting details is just going to lead to endless debate. My beef is more with the criteria than the process.