+ Palmer
- Rivers
Carson Palmer (19)
Philip Rivers (5)
Eliminated - Please do not Erase
Ben Roethlisberger
Steve McNair
Ron Mexico (aka Michael Vick)
Brett Favre
Aaron Brooks
Chad Pennington
Charlie Frye
Tom Brady
Byron Leftwich
Eli Manning
Kurt Warner
Donovan McNabb
Rex Grossman
Chris Simms
Alex Smith
Drew Bledsoe
Billy Volek
Mark Brunell
Marc Bulger
Jake Plummer
Trent Green
Drew Brees
Daunte Culpepper
JP Losman
Brad Johnson
Matt Hasselbeck
David Carr
Jon Kitna
Jake Delhomme
Peyton Manning