Yankees 1B VS. Red Sox 1B

[BuckFoston]

All you do is just choose what 1B you would rather have on your team. So here we go! Tino Martinez or Kevin Millar

[CrazyEights]

Kevin Millar! The Cardinals were so unhappy with Tino on their team that they gave him away and paid almost all of his salary.

[RockSports17]

If this was the old Tino vs. Millar. I would definitely say Tino. This Tino is old and is not as good as he once was. I think Millar produces much more than Tino can right now.

Tino is a great presence on the team though. He will always be remembered as a Yankee.

[PacMan]

1998- Duh Tino
Now- Tino is aging, I'd pick Millar

[CrazyEights]

The old Tino was a leader, and is obviously the better player. I don't think that's the case in 2005.

[Miss November]

If we're talking about present Tino, then I guess I'd have to pick...aw man do I hafta say it?




*Kevin Millar*

[Element]

This one is a no brainer.

[A's Baby Girl]

Could have included Giambi in the poll but too bad he sucks now :p

[Fishercat]

It's closer than people are giving the matchup credit for, but I'll take Millar. He had an off-year last year and was still as good as Tino.

[awefullspellare]

Millar by a lot IMO. I don't expect much from Tino this year.