I don't know too much about how Arod is playing this year I haven't watched too many Yankee games. But I know what type of player Arod is. Last year he did well in Clutch situations I beleive. Throughout his career he has choked in the playoffs. I imagine if Girardi wants to keep his job he has to play him. If he benches Arod he probably won't be around long. Course with them not playing well this year He might lose his job after the season.