AL Cy Young : Who SHOULD get it?

[General]

Ma-ri-a-no. There, I spelled it out.

[love_that_reefer]

No Cliff Lee talk?

[Kingdom]

I'd give it to Contreras before I'd give it to Jon "Judy" Garland.

[Lynch]

Johan Santana finished off the Twins season today with another win (16-7) throwing 9 K's in 7 innings giving up only 1 run and 3 hits.

The guy's stats are better than everyone in virtually every single category other than wins. Should win the CYA and will end up being a victim to dipshit sportswriters who only look at wins. I -still- say the players (in all sports) should be the ones voting for the awards as well as the all-stars.

*sigh*

[Halladay_is_God]

all rankings are for the AL only and yes ERA and Wins are not good stats but they count highly in the voters' mind

Colon: 21 wins (1st), 3.48 ERA (8th), 33 GS, 2 CG (T-10th), 222.2 IP (7th), 157 K's (T- 8th), 1.16 WHIP (3rd), 43 BB

Santana 16 wins (T-5th), 2.92 ERA (2nd), 33 GS, 3 CG (T-4th). 231.2 IP (2nd), 238 K's (1st), 0.98 (1st), 45 BB

case in point Santana should win but doesn't have enough wins to over throw Colon's very solid season with 5 more wins