That if his life was on the line for one game, he's taking Cliff Lee.
RealSkipBayless One gm for my life, give me Cliff Lee. Ubaldo: 0-2 in playoffs. Halladay 0 playoff starts. Last yr's playoffs: Lee 4-0, 1.54. Beat NY twice.
Yeah, we don't know what Halladay is capable of in the playoffs, but we know he could beat the AL East. We have no idea how Lincecum would be, but he does have two Cy Youngs. Jimenez is a year older, and a year better. And he's not even mentioning Jon Lester, Carpenter/Wainwright, or Santana.
So, would you take Lee in one game when your life depended on it?