Hit or no hit?

[Hardy Blonde]

He wouldn't be himself if he didn't

[HollywoodLeo]

If you ask me, it was probably an error. But, CC made the error, so I feel no sympathy. Additionally, CC wasn't even the one to complain, so I see no reason to reverse the decision just because the manager decides to whine.

It was an error (not a hit) regardless of who filed the complaint.

[bjd2933]

Eh, who cares once the game is over. No hitters and perfect games are all about suspense, and unless it was ruled an error before the 7th inning or so, the suspense and juice behind it was lost.

I'm glad they didn't rule it an error after the appeal. It would have been silly. It wasn't a clear error. As someone who pitched, its hard making plays down the third base line. Even if he grabs the ball, he still has to make throw. Its one of those situations that if they gave him an error, and a no-hitter wasn't going on, you would have watched the game and called it a harsh error.

CC handled it well, he's still young... he'll have plenty of opportunities to do it again. Who knows, with the way he has been pitching, he could toss a no-no next start.

[Hardy Blonde]

That'd be nice cuz their facing the Padres and since we aren't doing much tonight, tomorrow is another day!

[HollywoodLeo]

That'd be nice cuz their facing the Padres

I respectfully disagree

[Hardy Blonde]

I know that's why I said it