American League ROY?

[Rufio181]

Whoever doesn't think Verlander is on track for ROY is wrong. Very wrong.

[Fishercat]

I don't see how Melky's top 5.

Francisco/Verlander/Papelbon are easy takers. And I'd probably take Kinsler and Johjima over him

[Fishercat]

And Verlander will win the ROTY and is deserving at this point, but it doesn't mean he is necessarily the best candidate as we have two months left to determine that

[Rufio181]

And Verlander will win the ROTY and is deserving at this point, but it doesn't mean he is necessarily the best candidate as we have two months left to determine that

I just said he was on track. If he keeps pitching well for the next 2 months, Verlander is pretty much set.

[bernie132000]

Not saying he will win, but he should definately be in the top 5.

[DirtyKash]

Any love for Zumaya? He's lost in the discussion for being a setup man.

[Fishercat]

No, because Papelbon > Him

[Witlon]

I like it this way...

1) Verlander
2) Liriano
3) Papelbon
4) Kinsler
5) Markakis/Zumaya

Looks about right to me.

[DirtyKash]

Witlon, you forgot about Jered and Johjima.

[Witlon]

Holy shit...

1. Verlander
2. Lirinao
3. Papelbon
4. Weaver
5. Kinsler
6. Johjima
7. Zumaya
8. Markakis

[DirtyKash]

Someone stick a fork in Verlander, he's done.

[bernie132000]

I still think Markakis is in this. He has 8 HRs over his last 10 games. Hitting .308, with an OBP of .370, and a slugging of .471. He also plays amazing defense.

[bwitty24]

i think papelbon should win it...I think he still has an under 1 era whihch is remarkable.