Aaron Harang
Brandon Phillips
Bronson Arroyo
Ryan Freel
Adam Dunn
Edwin Encarnacion
David Ross
Scott Hatteberg
Ken Griffey Jr.
Voted off:
1. Quentin McCracken
2. Dave Williams
3. Jason LaRue
4. Joe Mays
5. Eric Milton
6. Brian Shackleford
7. Juan Castro
8. Royce Clayton
9. Javier Valentin
10. David Weathers
11. Brandon Claussen
12. Kyle Lohse
13. Gary Majewski
14. Rich Aurilia
15. Todd Coffey
16. Elizardo Ramirez
17. Rheal Cormier
18. Todd Hollandsworth
19. Chris Denorfia
20. Bill Bray
21. Eddie Guardado