Overall, I thought the piece was interesting but could have been done better.
The quote “Baseball, with its unshaking reliance on superstition, believes that the Red Sox have found themselves one lucky charm” is idiotic on more levels then I canre to go into at the moment...
Other random things that made me cringe during the piece:
-- James never said that catchers, not pitchers,prevent stolen bases.
-- “James became the voice of God to baseball geeks everywhere.”
-- “Even he admits the numbers can never say it all.”
I think it tried to come off as a piece on Sabermetrics as opposed to what it really was, a piece on exactly who Bill James is as a person and what he is like. I mean, maybe I'm wrong, but I just think the piece went at what they were trying to do from a questionable angle.